Planning Your Commodity Order Wisely Can Help You Reach the 30% NY Threshold

Becky O'Connor, Farm to School Coordinator, WNY & Finger Lakes
Harvest New York

June 3, 2020
Planning Your Commodity Order Wisely Can Help You Reach the 30% NY Threshold

Article by Rosemarie Hanson, Trumansburg Central School District Food Service Director, and Gail Brisson, Trumansburg Middle School Librarian; originally submitted to FOCUS Magazine.

If you are trying to increase your purchases of local and NY State foods to achieve the 30%, the first place you should look is your commodity ordering. When you are ordering your "brown box" items next year, consider leaving off the cheddar, mozzarella cheese and the ground beef. These are three products that are produced and readily available in New York State. This is an easy switch that doesn't increase your labor costs or require any special skills to implement.

What to spend your available commodity dollars on now that you are buying NY Cheese and beef? Grilled chicken strips are a great USDA center of the plate option that are fully cooked, easy to portion, and are a versatile protein to combine with local vegetables and international flavors in dishes kids will love. Diced chicken, turkey roasts, and roasted bone-in chicken are some other protein options that are often available.

The other items to take off of your commodity order are potatoes, carrots, and apple products. Fresh apples, apple sauce, and apple juice are all available as NYS products. NYS potatoes are available pretty much year round, and kids won't get sick of them even if you serve them every week. Baking russet potatoes and steaming whole red or "salt" potatoes are simple options that don't take too much labor. Other simple preparations are chopping and roasting, either as "home fries" or oven roasted wedges. Peeling carrots does take more work than buying already prepared "baby" carrots, but local carrots are often sweeter and will last a long time in the cooler. What to spend your available commodity dollars on now that you've eliminated these fruits and vegetables? Put your leftover dollars into the FFAVORS program or the Pilot program to buy produce that you can't buy locally, like oranges, or lettuce out of season.

Still not at 30%? Try increasing the frequency with which you serve NY items. Cheese is a pretty cost effective protein that kids love. Make your own "speed scratch" pizza with premade whole grain rich pizza shells, canned sauce, and NY mozzarella cheese, and menu it every week. Homemade macaroni and cheese with NY Cheddar is pretty easy to make, and is great paired with broccoli or cauliflower. Add more Mexican dishes like quesadillas, enchiladas, or tacos that use cheddar cheese. 

Items like NY Ground Beef may seem unaffordable at first glance, at 79 cents per 2 M/MA versus 51 cents for commodity beef. But by ordering chicken strips at 35 cents per serving, instead of USDA ground beef I get 50% more MMA for my commodity dollars, and they are more versatile. This goes a long way towards supporting my NY beef purchases. Another way that chicken strips can stretch my ground beef dollars is to also offer chicken taco filling when we have ground beef tacos. I have found that in some schools, more than 50% of the students choose the chicken.

By switching to NY beef, you will rapidly increase your total percentage of NY foods, and if this brings you to the 30% threshold, you will easily recoup the added expense. Local beef can also be safer for students; the beef that I get is tested for e. coli, has minimal hormones, and the source of the meat is traceable. And it happens to look and taste better than what I was getting in my commodity order.

Saving money by choosing commodity foods carefully can make room in your budget for buying local foods, and the rewards are greater than just the potential extra 19 cents per lunch; buying local supports our local economies, has a positive impact on the environment, and creates excitement and anticipation in your school lunch program.

Image credit Trumansburg CSD




Upcoming Events

Urban Ag Food Safety Webinar

March 11, 2026
12:00 pm - 1:30 pm

Urban and small-scale producers are encouraged to join us for the Urban Ag Food Safety webinar, featuring speakers from Cornell Cooperative Extension and Cornell IPM. We will explore the 'why' behind food safety, providing a basic overview and diving into specific urban ag considerations including water, pest, rodent, and soil health challenges. We will touch on the regulation and marketing landscape, and share resources for learning more. Bring your questions!

Companion Planting in the Garden -- With Mushrooms!

March 12, 2026
10:00 am - 11:30 am

Learn how to diversify your garden harvest with companion planting at this virtual workshop. Plan next spring's garden with guidance CCE Harvest NY Urban Agriculture Specialist Yolanda Gonzalez on growing three different types of mushrooms.

2026 Rochester Urban Agriculture Conference

March 21, 2026
9:00 am - 4:00 pm
Rochester, NY

Join us for our annual Rochester Urban Agriculture Conference, a day of learning and connections featuring interactive workshops, community knowledge sharing, Fruition's Gift of Seed Experience, horticulture tables and displays, and more!

Announcements

Community Gardens Soil Testing Program Accepting Applications

Soil testing supports the growth and expansion of community gardens by protecting the health and safety of the food produced in these gardens. CCE Harvest NY, in partnership with the NYS Department of Agriculture & Markets (AGM) and the Cornell Soil Health Lab, is offering eligible, food-producing gardens in New York State the opportunity to send soil samples for testing without charge.

The soil test will analyze samples for heavy metals and nutrient levels. Test results help gardeners make appropriate plans to produce high quality fruits, vegetables, and flowers. Technical support and education for participating growers will be available from the CCE Harvest New York team. Learn more about the 2026 Community Gardens Soil Testing Program.

2025 Year in Review

2025 was another year of growth and accomplishment for CCE Harvest NY! Our 2025 Year in Review highlights our impacts and details our work.
  • Farm to School Local Procurement by the Numbers
  • Biochar in the NYC Urban Agriculture Landscape
  • Harvest New York Supports Farmer-Led Research Advancing Upland Rice Production in New York State
  • Community Garden Soil Testing Program Yields Great Results
  • Regional Roots: Culinary Training to Enhance School Meals with Local Foods
  • Rooted in Learning: Strengthening Farm to School Connections Across New York
  • South Lawn Farm Expands Fresh Food Access and Urban Farming Opportunities
  • NYS Summit Advances the Mushroom Industry
  • Research to Manage Pests in Blueberries with Less Sprays
  • Building a Research and Extension Hub at Brooklyn Botanic Garden
  • A Successful Community Garden Leadership Program Pilot
  • Farm to School Events Deliver Education, Culinary Training, and Business to Business Opportunities
  • A Trusted Source of Science-Based Information for the Cannabis sativa Hemp Industry
  • Sustainable Pest Management for New York Urban Farmers
  • Cultivating Resilience: Harvest New York Drives the State's Climate Goals Through Research and Outreach
  • Expanding Agritourism Outreach Across New York State
  • Coordinating City Agencies, Academia, and Community Gardens to Improve Urban Soils
  • USDA Urban Agriculture Training Development Complete